
Map of Vietnam
Deceit and Impunity vs Piety and Resistance
The Vietnamese communist regime has betrayed a pledge made to return the historic Vatican Apostolic Nunciature in Hanoi to the Asian country’s Catholics, completely destroying the embassy building for the ostensible purpose of clearing the land for a park.
The Federation of Vietnamese Catholic Mass Media has extensive coverage, mostly in Vietnamese, but also reproduces and links to articles in European languages. The persecution the Catholics have faced throughout their campaign to recover the expropriated land and buildings reveals that the rights of all Vietnamese are subject to the whims of the rulers of the Socialist Republic.
No Good Faith from the Faithless
Concord Live reported in February on the courage of the Vietnamese Catholics engaging in acts of nonviolent struggle, holding prayer vigils and peaceful demonstrations to demand the return of lands belonging to the Church that were seized by the incoming revolutionaries in the 1950s. In our previous story, we warned:
Embassy Handover Promised, but Uncertain. Concord Live will continue to watch this story as the actual handover has yet to occur and there is no reason to attribute good faith to a murderous tyranny like the Socialist Republic. In fact, a secret police operation to investigate the demonstrators is underway. Under Vietnamese law, all land is state property, and the resources of the State may be brought down swiftly upon dissenting voices.
Catholics Respond with Increasing Nonviolent Mobilization; Communists Increase Violent Repression
Catholic news services and blogs have been following this story very closely and reveal a resilient and determined Catholic movement to demand respect for rights long denied, perhaps even at the price of martyrdom. Catholic Culture / Catholic World News reports:
Church-state tensions continue to escalate: bishops are threatened with arrest; Redemptorist priests at a parish involved in another property dispute have even been threatened with death.
The media in Hanoi have charged that Archbishop Joseph Ngo Quang Kiet is inciting riots by expressing his support for demonstrated who opposed the demolition process. The media have consistently depicted the demonstrators as threats to public safety.
In a letter to the government leaders of Vietnam, Bishop Michael Hoang Duc Oanh of Kontum, warned that this campaign of vilification could have grave consequences. “Our people are gentle and kind, easy to forget the past and forgive those who trespass against them.” However “when they find themselves being tricked, pushed to the corner, and persecuted… they can accept even death”…
At the nunciature, construction workers worked throughout the night to demolish the building. Thousands of Catholics have protested around the clock.
Sunday morning saw the largest demonstration in the history of Vietnam since the Communist takeover, with hundreds of priests leading more than 10,000 Catholic protestors in a prayerful vigil outside the gate of the nunciature. Bishop Joseph Dang Duc Ngan of Lang Son lead the prayers, as police accompanied by attack dogs patrolled the fence lined with barbed wire that had been installed at the site.
The Federation of Vietnamese Catholic Mass Media issued a statement of “deep concerns about religious and human-rights violations against Catholics.” Citing the property disputes at the nunciature and at a Redemptorist monastery in Thai Ha parish, the group confessed: “We are at our wit’s end as the injustice being done to our brothers and sisters in Christ– to the unarmed, religious people whose only weapon to protect themselves and property has always been praying with an unshaken belief in God”…
…[A] large crowd appeared at the Thai Ha parish on Sunday, throwing stones, smashing statues, and shouting threats against the Redemptorist priests. One of the priests observed that “everything happened clearly in front of a large number of officials– police, security personnel, anti-riot police… but they did nothing to protect us.”
Associated Press Journalist Beaten; AP Reports Tensions
The Associated Press has a current report on this story that skips over the blatant about-face by the regime:
Communist authorities in Hanoi have threatened to take legal action against the city’s archbishop unless he immediately disbands illegal prayer vigils to demand the return of former church lands, state media reported Monday.
The government campaign against Archbishop Ngo Quang Kiet escalated over the weekend, with state television calling into question his patriotism in an apparent attempt to turn public opinion against him.
State-controlled newspapers on Monday quoted a letter to Kiet from Hanoi Mayor Nguyen The Thao, accusing the cleric of instigating unrest.
“Stop your illegal acts immediately or you will be dealt with according to the law,” Thao was quoted as writing. “You have a responsibility to persuade priests and parishioners to abide by the law.”
Prayer is only allowed at church under Vietnamese law. The reports did not specify what form the legal action might take.
Catholics have been holding sporadic prayer vigils this year to demand the return of two plots of land once owned by the church but seized decades ago by communist authorities. One is near Thai Ha Church, not far from the center of Hanoi, while the other is the site of the former Vatican Embassy, next to St. Joseph’s Cathedral, the city’s biggest church.
The vigils have put great pressure on Hanoi officials, who are eager to project an image of religious tolerance but determined to maintain political control.
On Friday, the city began bulldozing the grounds of the former Vatican Embassy to clear the land for a public park and library.
Over the weekend, the crowds near the site grew as hundred of Catholics attended weekend masses at St. Joseph’s. They were closely watched by riot police and other security officers.
City officials say the land belongs to Hanoi and will not be returned to the church. Church officials say they have old documents proving the land belongs to them…
The city announced last week that it would use the St. Joseph’s site for a library and park. Catholics have long said they believed the city planned to sell the valuable land to private developers. Monday’s report on state TV said city officials also plan to transform the 20,000 square-yard (17,000-square-meter) Thai Ha site into a public park…
AP Hanoi Chief of Bureau Ben Stocking was brutally beaten for covering one of the prayer vigils. Apparently showing Vietnamese secret police treating a peaceful gathering as a threat to their iron grip on power may be bad for foreign investment:
AP Hanoi Chief of Bureau Ben Stocking emerged from a police station Friday with matted blood on his head and trousers, and a gash in his head requiring four stitches. He reported that he had been choked, punched and bashed with his own camera — the last assault opening a cut in his scalp that bled profusely. After his 2 1/2 hours in detention, he immediately had to seek treatment at a private clinic for the head injury.
Nevertheless, a foreign ministry statement disputed that there had been a beating.
“There was no beating of Mr. Ben Stocking by the Vietnamese security force,” read the statement attributed to Foreign Ministry spokesman Le Dung and posted on the Foreign Ministry Web site.
“Stocking broke the Vietnamese law by deliberately taking pictures at a place where taking pictures was not allowed,” the statement said. “Officers who were on duty to keep the public order warned him, but Mr. Stocking did not follow.”
More Coverage of the Catholic Struggle in Vietnam
Here are some further reports:
Asia News: Thugs attack Thai Ha Catholics as police look on
Catholic News Agency: Vietnamese gang ransacks Catholic chapel as police stand by
ZENIT: Catholics Lose Land Battle With Hanoi
Catholic News Agency: Vietnamese Catholics continue struggle for land despite government threats
Catholic News Agency: Vietnam to return confiscated lands to prominent Catholic basilica
Catholic Culture / Catholic World News: Vietnamese nuns protest for return of property
Catholic Culture / Catholic World News: Viet Catholics continue vigils over disputed property
Catholic Culture / Catholic World News: Viet media call for crackdown on Catholic protests
Catholic Culture / Catholic World News: Viet authorities promise to return land around La Vang shrine
Catholic News Agency: Vietnam state-owned media ramps up attacks on Catholic demonstrators
ZENIT- Francais: Vietnam : Manifestations de prière pour la restitution d’un terrain
[Note the contrast in the following two articles between Communist-sanctioned and underground Buddhist leaders.]
Catholic News Agency: Buddhists enter Catholics’ property dispute with Vietnamese government
Catholic Culture / Catholic World News: Viet Buddhist leader backs Catholic claim to Hanoi property
Catholic Culture / Catholic World News: Viet government repeats promise on restoring property
Pay No Attention to the Man Behind the [Iron] Curtain
Just as Concord Live’s last post on the FARC’s mounting defeats and the radical Latin American left’s material and political support for them was published, news broke of Venezuelan dictator Hugo Chavez’s calls to the FARC to free their hostages and end their guerrilla strategy. Helen Murphy, writing for Bloomberg, has a summary of the situation as it stands:
The governments of Colombia and the United States welcomed his words, but his actions remain to be seen.
Shifting Tactics Continue to Foment Violence and Revolution in Latin America and the Caribbean
Given the following:
First, that Interpol certified the computer files and documents obtained on the Colombian Army’s raid resulting in the killing of Raul Reyes, and that this evidence showed Hugo Chavez a willing direct sponsor of FARC terrorism;
Second, that this year’s bid to gain the FARC legitimate belligerent status fell absolutely flat, resulting rather in today’s announced European Union-United States call for the release of all hostages held by armed groups in South America as well as freedom for all of Cuba’s over 300 political prisoners;
Third, that the strategy of creating radical regimes through the ballot box rather than through military-driven revolution (woe to ye who think that the ballot box embodies any kind of procedural democratic guarantee when dealing with determined people with Marxist ideology and aims) has worked well enough to bring Hugo Chavez, Evo Morales, Rafael Correa, and Daniel Ortega to power in the Twenty-First Century Socialism coalition nurtured by totalitarian Cuba’s Fidel and Raul Castro, and to bring the Farabundo Marti Liberation Front (the political home of El Salvador’s vicious 1980s terrorist guerrillas) within striking distance of winning El Salvador’s next elections;
And fourth, that Chavez was offering $300 million to finance the FARC’s operations (land mines, child soldiers, and targeting of civilians included) even as he shuttled from Venezuela to Colombia on a purported mission of mercy to gain the release of hostages, which served as a pretext for his belligerent status drive;
it is reasonable to conclude that this public position taken by the Venezuelan dictator:
First, is a reaction to the political cost of the intelligence revelations from Raul Reyes’s files, chiefly in the form of the international pressure alluded to in the second point;
Next, that there is no reason why the FARC might decline to aim to continue destabilizing Colombia for another 50 years if its members ostensibly demilitarize and compete politically to achieve the same kind of bloody rule under which they have kept the Colombian interior for decades;
Next, that the Twenty-First Century Socialist coalition will continue cooperating to support radical leftist agendas whether under the guise of guerrilla forces, political parties, student and youth movements to the detriment of the people of Latin America who will continue to be denied freedom, peace, and the opportunity for prosperity;
And finally, that as long as Cuba remains under the rule of a regime that terrorizes its people and remains determined to export revolution, Latin America and the Caribbean will be especially prone to tyranny and material poverty.
Leave a Comment
Posted in Commentary | Tags: Alvaro Uribe, Analysis, Colombia, Commentary, Cuba, Ecuador, FARC, Hostages, Hugo Chavez, New World, Nicaragua, Political Prisoners, Revolution, Terrorism, Twenty-First Century Socialism, United States of America, Venezuela